On the north side of Main Road in Jamesport, a preserved farm runs from the road nearly to Sound Avenue. It is 107 acres of barns, paddocks and a full-size track built for trotters. Debra and Kenneth Rothwell closed on it on Feb. 13 for $3.5 million and kept its six-person staff and roughly 50 boarded horses. They now run it as Thunder Road Stables, the North Fork Sun reported in August. Suffolk County bought the farm's development rights in 1979. That makes it one of the county's earlier preserved farms, and it means the open fields beside the hamlet center stay open.
Behind those fields, Jamesport's housing market had its busiest year in some time. More Jamesport owners put their homes up for sale, and buyers took almost all of them at prices close to last year's. For anyone choosing between Jamesport and the hamlets to its east, that difference decides how to approach the winter.
Twice the sales, nearly the same price
OneKey MLS data covers the 12 months through October 2026. In that window, Jamesport closed 34 single-family sales, up from 16 in the prior 12 months. New listings rose to 40 from 29. The 12-month median sale price moved from $938,750 to $982,000, a gain of 4.6%.
| Jamesport single-family, 12 months through October | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Closed sales | 16 | 34 |
| New listings | 29 | 40 |
| Median sale price | $938,750 | $982,000 |
| Average days on market | 101 | 85 |
| Average homes for sale | 14 | 9 |
The order of events matters here. Eleven more homes came to market than the year before, and sales rose by 18. Buyers took the new supply and also drew down what had been sitting. The average number of homes for sale over the period fell from 14 to 9. Over the same 12 months, sellers got 92.1% of their original asking price on average, a little below the 93.4% of the year before. Sellers were settling a few points below their first asking price, and the median moved only modestly.
A single quarter can show a bigger jump than the rolling year, because it depends on which homes happen to close in those three months. For the third quarter of 2026, one East End brokerage report counted 20 Jamesport single-family sales against 9 a year earlier, with the median rising from $845,000 to $994,500. The mix of homes behind those medians changed. In the third quarter of 2025, seven of the nine sales fell between $750,000 and $1 million, and only one closed above $1 million. In the third quarter of 2026, half of the 20 sales still fell between $750,000 and $1 million, but eight closed above $1 million, two of them between $2 million and $5 million. The core price range in Jamesport held steady. More larger homes happened to close in the same three months, and they pulled the quarterly median up.
The rest of the North Fork shows the same summer pattern. Another brokerage's third-quarter report counted 99 single-family sales across the North Fork, up 22% from a year earlier. Aquebogue/Jamesport and Mattituck/Laurel each added 11 sales, while Cutchogue, Greenport and East Marion/Orient each had one to three fewer. In that report, the North Fork-wide median fell 14% to $964,000. Homes under $1 million made up 58% of third-quarter sales, up from 43% a year earlier. Nearly all of the North Fork's added sales came from its western end, and they came mostly from the price bands where Jamesport has the most homes.
What actually changed hands, street by street
The weekly transfer lists in the North Fork Sun put addresses to those numbers. Across Jamesport's 11947 ZIP code from July through October, the recorded sales were spread fairly evenly across the low and high ends of the market.
| Address | Price | Records week |
|---|---|---|
| 177 Herricks Lane | $525,000 | Ending Aug. 7 |
| 133 High Meadow Lane | $699,500 | Ending Aug. 7 |
| 51 Lockitt Drive | $750,000 | Oct. 25 issue |
| 108 Vista Court | $800,000 | July 26 issue |
| 93 Saint Marys Drive | $800,000 | July 26 issue |
| 752 Peconic Bay Boulevard | $810,000 | Ending Aug. 28 |
| 61 Eileen Circle | $999,000 | Ending Sept. 4 |
| 59 Lockitt Drive | $1,185,000 | Ending Sept. 4 |
| 213 Herricks Lane | $1,250,000 | Ending Sept. 25 |
| 33 Dougs Lane | $1,685,000 | Ending Sept. 4 |
| 55 Seacove Lane | $1,735,000 | Ending Aug. 28 |
| 105 Lockitt Drive | $1,950,000 | Ending Sept. 25 |
Two streets show up more than once. Lockitt Drive has three entries. LLCs bought 59 Lockitt Drive and 51 Lockitt Drive, and 105 Lockitt Drive sold from an LLC to individual buyers for $1.95 million. Herricks Lane has two, at $525,000 and $1.25 million. A buyer could find either end of the market on one road this year.
South Jamesport, which has its own ZIP code, 11970, is a separate market from the hamlet. It recorded 957 Peconic Bay Boulevard at $1.595 million in July. In the records week ending Sept. 4, it recorded 49 Dunlookin Lane at $6 million, the largest residential figure on the western North Fork lists this summer. A buyer comparing Jamesport prices should keep the two ZIP codes apart. One bayfront sale in 11970 says little about a $900,000 house north of Peconic Bay Boulevard.
The busy year left a thin winter inventory
Many of the homes that came to market this year have already sold. In October 2026, Jamesport had 7 single-family homes for sale, against 13 in October 2025. Only 2 new listings came on during the month. At October's pace, that inventory works out to about 2.5 months of supply.
The homes that did sell in October sold faster and closer to their asking prices than a year earlier. There were 3 closings at an $890,000 median. Average time on market was 42 days, down from 125 in October 2025. Sellers received 95.7% of their original asking price, against 81.7% a year earlier. A single month with three sales can swing a lot. Even so, the October figures point the same way as the inventory count. The homes still on the market are being priced to sell, and they are selling.
For a buyer, this means Jamesport's prices have held near the $1 million mark for the past 12 months, but the choice of homes has shrunk. Expect a short list of homes this winter rather than higher prices. Anyone hoping for a certain street, lot or style may have to wait for spring listings, or be ready to move quickly when one of a handful of winter listings fits.
For an owner thinking about listing, the same numbers point the other way. With 2 new listings in October and 7 homes for sale, a well-prepared Jamesport house faces little direct competition until spring brings new inventory.
Main Road's big parcels went to farmers and a stable
The other change in Jamesport this year happened on land rather than in houses. The former B.J. Farms covered 163 acres along Main Road. It was listed as a whole and then split into three parcels to find buyers, Behind the Hedges reported in March. The Rothwells' preserved acreage at 1394 Main Road is the largest piece. The farm grew potatoes until the late 1970s, became a thoroughbred facility under Robert W. Entenmann, and was run by the Nixon family as B.J. Farms for more than three decades.
Farmer Patty Gentry bought the 22 acres at 1408 Main Road for $2.4 million to move her Early Girl Farm organic operation from Brookhaven. In the same Behind the Hedges report, she said soil preparation comes first and full operation will take about two years. The third piece, about 32 acres at 1386 Main Road with its development rights intact, sold to Kinexion Inc. for $2.9 million and closed June 4, according to RiverheadLOCAL's transfer report. Kinexion also bought the commercial property at 1374 Main Road from Jamesport Center LLC for $825,000, in the records week ending Oct. 23.
Elsewhere on the same road, a long-vacant homestead at 1117 Main Road was the subject of a pre-submission concept in August for a 20-room country inn and wellness retreat that would reuse its historic houses and barns. RiverheadLOCAL reported that town planners saw substantial zoning obstacles. The concept is an early proposal and has not been approved.
For a buyer weighing Jamesport against the rest of the North Fork, the Main Road sales show what surrounds the hamlet. The largest piece of the B.J. Farms tract stays preserved farmland with horses on it. A second piece is becoming an organic farm. The 32-acre parcel at 1386 Main Road, which still carries its development rights, is the one to follow at Riverhead Town planning meetings.
If you're weighing a Jamesport purchase this winter, or wondering whether your own house should be one of the few listed before spring, Cheryl & Regan can walk you through this year's Jamesport sales street by street and price your home against what actually closed. Request a personalized market consultation and free home valuation, and we'll start with the numbers on your street.